You hear a song for the first time and something inconvenient happens: you recognise it.
Not because you have actually heard it before, or because it resembles some half-forgotten single your parents owned, but because the feeling is already there waiting for it.
Most people have had this happen. A piece of music catches you at exactly the wrong angle and suddenly there is a place attached to it: a kitchen at dusk, a motorway seen through rain, the hallway of a house you never lived in, some inexplicable Sunday afternoon from 1974 despite the fairly serious problem of you not being alive in 1974. Music is capable of making the brain commit fraud against its own autobiography.
Can’s She Brings the Rain is one of the purest examples of this I know.
It does not really start. It seems to have been playing quietly somewhere before you arrived. A bassline walks into view at a pace suggesting it has nowhere important to be, guitar phrases drift around it, and Malcolm Mooney sings as though he has been sitting at the neighbouring table for half an hour. Within seconds the record has acquired architecture.
Mine is a hotel bar somewhere in Europe.
I could not tell you which country, and establishing one would ruin it. The carpet is dark red and has survived several attempts at refurbishment. There is a brass lamp on a small table performing no useful function whatsoever. Rain is travelling slowly down a window overlooking a railway line, while somewhere nearby there is a station buffet that closed twenty minutes ago and will not reopen until morning. You have missed the last train, although it is unclear where you were intending to go.
I have never been there.
That is the interesting bit.
Nothing in She Brings the Rain describes this place. There are no railway stations in the lyric, no hotels, no terrible carpet. Yet the song produces the sensation of recovering something rather than encountering something new. For four minutes, German experimental rock has somehow convinced you that you once spent an evening in a town whose name you cannot remember.
That peculiar confusion between imagination and memory is where the song begins to feel hauntological.
Can are not necessarily the band you would expect to make something this quietly seductive. Their reputation has accumulated all the usual intimidating furniture: experimental, avant-garde, krautrock, hugely influential, rhythmic pioneers. These are useful descriptions, but they also make putting on a Can record sound suspiciously like accepting homework.
She Brings the Rain requires almost nothing from you.
Its bassline is absurdly relaxed. Rather than pushing the song forward, it strolls through it with the confidence of someone who knows the barman personally. There is something faintly jazzy about the whole arrangement, but thankfully not enough to encourage anyone nearby to explain jazz. The guitar appears in loose fragments, answering without interrupting, while Mooney’s voice never seems particularly concerned with proving that it is the centre of attention.
This restraint is what gives the song its power. A great deal of music that wants to create atmosphere behaves like a restaurant determined to prove it has atmosphere: candles everywhere, low lighting, several unnecessary plants and someone asking whether you have enjoyed “the ambience” before you have removed your coat.
Can simply leave space.
The gaps between the instruments matter almost as much as the instruments themselves. Nothing is fighting to occupy every available inch, so the recording develops depth. You begin to hear not merely sounds but distances between sounds, and those distances slowly turn into rooms.
It is why She Brings the Rain feels less like a song playing inside a space than a song capable of generating the space itself.
There is also remarkably little sense of destination. Most popular songs, even excellent ones, are built around expectation. A verse points towards a chorus, the chorus returns you to familiar ground, and eventually a bridge appears because everyone deserves a brief change of scenery before going home.
Pop music has public transport.
She Brings the Rain seems to have lost the timetable.
It moves without appearing particularly interested in arrival. You are not waiting for some enormous chorus to tell you why the previous minute mattered, and there is no dramatic climax lurking further down the track. The experience is closer to watching the light change through a window.
This makes the song unusually resistant to exhaustion. Plenty of records become victims of their own familiarity. Once you know every transition and every payoff, you begin hearing the machinery rather than the illusion. There is very little machinery to expose here.
You do not return to She Brings the Rain because you have forgotten what happens. You return because you want the conditions again, in much the same way that nobody listens to actual rainfall while waiting for the plot to develop.
The title is almost comically simple considering how much it contains. She does not stand in the rain or arrive during it; she brings it. Weather belongs to her presence.
That immediately turns the woman into something stranger than a straightforward romantic subject. She becomes part person and part atmospheric disturbance, the sort of figure who could appear at the end of a road while the clouds quietly decide to rearrange themselves.
Whether this is desirable remains wonderfully unclear.
Rain can rescue a garden, destroy a wedding, clean a city, flood a cellar or provide an extremely persuasive argument for not going anywhere. Britain has spent several hundred years complaining about it while arranging much of its emotional life around windows. To say somebody “brings the rain” therefore contains far more than simple sadness.
Mooney never settles the matter for us.
There is no grand declaration in his performance, no sense that he is about to collapse beneath the emotional importance of what he is saying. He sounds observant rather than devastated, almost amused by whatever effect this person has on him.
That emotional distance makes the song more intimate rather than less.
Relationships often change life in exactly this unspectacular way. Somebody appears and nothing obvious moves. The kitchen remains the kitchen, the buses still run late, your phone charger is still inexplicably in the wrong room, and Tesco continues asking whether you have a Clubcard.
Yet Tuesday feels different.
That is usually how the important changes arrive. Nobody announces them. There is no soundtrack swelling behind the first occasion you realise someone has begun occupying a slightly unreasonable amount of your internal life.
You simply notice that the weather has changed.
Perhaps that is why She Brings the Rain feels romantic without behaving like a conventional love song. It does not tell us what a relationship means. It describes the alteration in pressure surrounding it.
Calling that rain may be more accurate than calling it love.
There is another reason the record feels strangely disconnected from its own period. It is obviously an old recording, yet it does not sit comfortably inside the idea of “old music”. Many records eventually acquire historical labels whether they want them or not. Production techniques date them, fashions pin them down, entire decades start growing around them like ivy.
She Brings the Rain somehow avoids being completely claimed by 1970.
It sounds old, but the past it belongs to is difficult to locate. This is not cosy nostalgia. There are no comforting childhood objects lined up for recognition, nothing equivalent to seeing an old chocolate wrapper and immediately announcing that everything tasted better before decimalisation.
Instead, the nostalgia arrives without an object.
You feel that something has been lost before you have established what the missing thing was.
This is the point where hauntology becomes more useful than nostalgia as an idea. Nostalgia generally depends upon ownership: I remember this, I had this, I was there. Hauntology is more interested in the suspicion that something has survived which never properly happened in the first place.
Music is extremely good at producing that suspicion.
Memory itself is unreliable enough to help. We forget entire months and preserve ridiculous details. Someone can disappear from our lives and eventually become difficult to picture, while the wallpaper behind them remains inexplicably crisp.
Atmosphere survives facts.
Perhaps this explains why certain recordings become more powerful as they age. Their details start escaping the circumstances that produced them. The original studio becomes irrelevant, the intended audience disappears, fashions move on, but the sensation remains intact.
A record then stops functioning only as a document of its own period. It becomes something capable of haunting periods that came afterwards.
She Brings the Rain feels particularly suited to this because it was already slightly displaced when it appeared. Can were making music that did not behave reliably like rock, jazz or pop, and this track in particular seems to have wandered out of some adjacent cultural history where lounge music became experimental without anybody noticing.
It would be easy for that mixture to become pastiche. Instead it feels completely sincere.
Can understood something many experimental musicians occasionally forget: strangeness does not require unpleasantness. You do not have to attack a piano with agricultural machinery to make familiar forms unsettling.
Sometimes it is enough to alter their proportions.
A perfectly ordinary room becomes disturbing if one wall turns out to be several inches longer than it ought to be. She Brings the Rain works on much the same principle. Nothing in it is especially alien, yet everything sits slightly outside its expected position.
The longer you remain there, the harder it becomes to determine where “there” actually is.
By the time the song ends, the place it created has become surprisingly convincing. The imaginary hotel bar still seems to exist somewhere beyond the edge of the recording, with its pointless brass lamp and its window facing the railway.
Then the final sound disappears and the actual room begins returning.
There was no hotel. You never missed that train. Nobody was standing outside under the yellow light, and there is no European town whose name you ought to remember.
None of it happened.
Yet She Brings the Rain leaves you with the faint ache of having left somewhere behind.
Can managed to give you the nostalgia before giving you the memory.
And perhaps that is hauntology at its simplest: missing a past you never had.
Leave a Reply